Policing in patriarchy

Job ID: 35431443

Budget: $10 – $30 USD

Research q: What is the impact of police reform (WHD) on gender-based violence (GBV) for women in India? What encourages women to report cases of gender-based violence (GBV)?

Four components of the WHD intervention:
1. Private spaces (such as a room or cubicle) for female complaints within police stations;
2. Standard operating procedures on how to register cases and assist women visitors, along with officer training on those procedures and routine implementation monitoring;
3. Outreach to local women’s and community safety networks;
4. Assignment of female officers (at the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector or higher) to run the WHDs.

Police stations – the unit of randomization – assigned to
- the first treatment arm of 61 stations (“regular” WHDs) received the first three components,
- while those assigned to the second arm of 59 stations (woman-run WHDs) received all four components. WHDs in the second treatment arm were directed to have designated female officers (with 90% compliance). While there was no prohibition on assigning female officers to WHDs in the first treatment arm, most (72% percent) were run by male officers.
- The control group of 60 stations continued with business as usual.

Contains data from 5 sources between Nov 2018 to December 2020
Specifically, it contains data from five sources, collected between November 2018 and December 2020:
i) Administrative data on crimes registered by the police
Admin_long data.dta: data is at the station-month- year level
Admin_wide data.dta: data is at the station-month level;

ii) CCTV data from the video feeds of cameras, present in all police stations, focused on the station entrance
Cctv_baseline data.dta: data is at the station-day-shift level.
Cctv_full data.dta: data is at the station-day-shift level.;

iii) A user survey of members of the public who had visited study police stations, asking about their satisfaction with their visit
User survey_endline data.dta: data is at the individual level.;

iv) A police survey, carried out at baseline and endline, of personnel in different roles and ranks in study stations
Police_baseline data.dta: data is at the individual level.
Police_full data.dta: data is at the individual level.
Police_personnel data.dta: data is at the station level.;

v) A survey of citizens, carried out at baseline and endline on perceptions of safety, opinions of and contact with the police, and experiences of crimes
Citizen_caw rates.dta: data is at the station level.
Citizen_full data.dta: data is at the household level.

Some key variables
- treatment: dummy variable (treatment group = 1, control group = 0)
- group: string variable showing the classification of treatment and control groups
- regular_whd: dummy variable (treatment arm 1, or regular WHD = 1, others = 0)
- women_whd dummy variable (treatment arm 2, or women-run WHD = 1, others = 0)
Related categories: Research Health & Medicine Research Writing