Review my study
Budget: $30 – $250 USD
I have already submitted my study to the journal. But, my works need minor
Plz find below the comments of the reviewers//
"Recommendation: Revisions Required
------------------------------------------------------
Study aims and rationale
The study aims are clearly stated in the manuscript and refer to enough previous works.
But the introduction section might be shorter, I get the impression that it's a little redundant.
Methods and replicability
The method section is described well and the research has ethical approval.
No statistical approach was used in this research except for the extraction of meaning by NVivo.
However, I did not evaluate the structure of the interview because I did not have access to the supplementary materials.
Results and Conclusions
I recommend using a table of comments from participants in each theme, It would be convenient for the reader to read this manuscript.
Discussion and Limitations
This manuscript is discussing the current situation of pharmacists in Saudi Arabia and issues with participating in mental health care.
The authors indicated that 'the finding is constituent with other studies' however I recommend discussing more focused on mental health care.
ie., What is similar with other studies and what is not similar with other studies. To add these points, the authors can show the usefulness of this paper.
The authors should add the limitation of this research. This is very important for future research.
Structure and Formatting
No problem with the format and structure.
The number of words is within the limit.
As indicated in the above part, please add the limitation of this study.
Language and Grammar
There are minor language and grammar issues that can be resolved during copy editing and proofreading
Does the manuscript contain new and significant research material/findings to warrant publication?
The paper can be expectable for publication and give readers the detailed background of pharmacists in Saudi Arabia and their relationship with other HCPs.
Reviewer recommendation:
MINOR revisions
Comments to Author(s):
Excellent work but I recommend adding comments for limitation of this research and consider to concise in the introduction."
Please,could you consider the comments before resubmitting the study?
Plz find below the comments of the reviewers//
"Recommendation: Revisions Required
------------------------------------------------------
Study aims and rationale
The study aims are clearly stated in the manuscript and refer to enough previous works.
But the introduction section might be shorter, I get the impression that it's a little redundant.
Methods and replicability
The method section is described well and the research has ethical approval.
No statistical approach was used in this research except for the extraction of meaning by NVivo.
However, I did not evaluate the structure of the interview because I did not have access to the supplementary materials.
Results and Conclusions
I recommend using a table of comments from participants in each theme, It would be convenient for the reader to read this manuscript.
Discussion and Limitations
This manuscript is discussing the current situation of pharmacists in Saudi Arabia and issues with participating in mental health care.
The authors indicated that 'the finding is constituent with other studies' however I recommend discussing more focused on mental health care.
ie., What is similar with other studies and what is not similar with other studies. To add these points, the authors can show the usefulness of this paper.
The authors should add the limitation of this research. This is very important for future research.
Structure and Formatting
No problem with the format and structure.
The number of words is within the limit.
As indicated in the above part, please add the limitation of this study.
Language and Grammar
There are minor language and grammar issues that can be resolved during copy editing and proofreading
Does the manuscript contain new and significant research material/findings to warrant publication?
The paper can be expectable for publication and give readers the detailed background of pharmacists in Saudi Arabia and their relationship with other HCPs.
Reviewer recommendation:
MINOR revisions
Comments to Author(s):
Excellent work but I recommend adding comments for limitation of this research and consider to concise in the introduction."
Please,could you consider the comments before resubmitting the study?
Related categories:
Research Writing
Medical Writing
Academic Writing
Academic Medicine
Academic Research