Journal Article Critique
Budget: $30 – $250 USD
Select an article published within the last 5 years based on a topic relating to plant ecology
from a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Points will be deducted if your article does not meet all of
these criteria.
The article must be a primary research article that describes an experiment. You may not use
a review article or a meta-analysis (If the paper you select is not a primary research article describing
an experiment, you will receive zero points for the assignment. Therefore, check with your instructor
if you are unsure whether your article meets the required criteria or not). After reading the article,
write a 2-page critique paper (double-spaced, Font Times New Roman, 12) based on your paper
including the following:
(1) A summary of the study.
Statement of the problem, issue, and/or question(s) discussed.
Briefly summarize the researchers' purpose for doing the research. (i.e. How is this contributing to science? Why are the researchers looking at this topic? Ex. Has it been poorly studied? Is it addressing a concern like climate change or invasive species - topics we need to understand better to manage? Etc.) This is different than a
statement of the question they are testing. It is the reason why they are testing this particular question.
Summarize the general approach or methods used, the hypothesis or hypotheses tested, and major conclusions.
Do not use direct quotes from the paper. Use your own words to describe the study.
The same applies to the evaluation portion of your critique.
(2) An evaluation of the article. (This should be the majority of your critique)
Is the writing appropriate and clear?
Has the author been objective in his or her discussion of the topic?
Are the methods described adequately? Be sure to explain why or why not.
Were the methods that were used appropriate for the question being asked? Why or why not?
Did the study adequately and completely test the question/hypothesis? Why or why not?
Is all of the discussion relevant? Why or why not?
Should some sections of the manuscript be expanded, condensed or omitted? Why or why not?
Do you agree with the researchers' conclusions? Why or why not?
Can you think of any other possible explanations for what they saw that they may not have thought of?
If you had done the study, what would you have done differently?
from a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Points will be deducted if your article does not meet all of
these criteria.
The article must be a primary research article that describes an experiment. You may not use
a review article or a meta-analysis (If the paper you select is not a primary research article describing
an experiment, you will receive zero points for the assignment. Therefore, check with your instructor
if you are unsure whether your article meets the required criteria or not). After reading the article,
write a 2-page critique paper (double-spaced, Font Times New Roman, 12) based on your paper
including the following:
(1) A summary of the study.
Statement of the problem, issue, and/or question(s) discussed.
Briefly summarize the researchers' purpose for doing the research. (i.e. How is this contributing to science? Why are the researchers looking at this topic? Ex. Has it been poorly studied? Is it addressing a concern like climate change or invasive species - topics we need to understand better to manage? Etc.) This is different than a
statement of the question they are testing. It is the reason why they are testing this particular question.
Summarize the general approach or methods used, the hypothesis or hypotheses tested, and major conclusions.
Do not use direct quotes from the paper. Use your own words to describe the study.
The same applies to the evaluation portion of your critique.
(2) An evaluation of the article. (This should be the majority of your critique)
Is the writing appropriate and clear?
Has the author been objective in his or her discussion of the topic?
Are the methods described adequately? Be sure to explain why or why not.
Were the methods that were used appropriate for the question being asked? Why or why not?
Did the study adequately and completely test the question/hypothesis? Why or why not?
Is all of the discussion relevant? Why or why not?
Should some sections of the manuscript be expanded, condensed or omitted? Why or why not?
Do you agree with the researchers' conclusions? Why or why not?
Can you think of any other possible explanations for what they saw that they may not have thought of?
If you had done the study, what would you have done differently?