Analysis of a Professional Journal Article for Readability and Pseudoscience versus Real Science
Budget: $10 – $30 USD
1-2 pages
Find a technical article from a high quality professional technical journal**, preferably
from a key professional organization in your major, choose one within the group. Note
the differences between professional journals and magazines. This makes a difference in
trusting the validity of the data (#3 below). It must be dated 2011-2019.
! What is a Journal analysis?
A rhetorical analysis of the conventions, language, audience, intent, and content
of a specific journal from the humanities, the analysis of an essay of your choice
from the journal, a discussion of what you believe it takes to be published in
that journal.
A "journal," or "scholarly journal," is a scholarly periodical aimed at
specialists and researchers. Articles are generally written by experts in
the subject, using more technical language. They contain original research,
conclusions based on data, footnotes or endnotes, and often an abstract or
bibliography.
Pseudoscience includes beliefs, theories, or practices that have been or
are considered scientific, but have no basis in scientific fact. This could mean
they were disproved scientifically, can't be tested scientifically, or lack evidence
to support them
1. Determine its main topic and get a general idea of what it is about and how it is
organized. Make a note of what the article’s purpose is and who the article’s intended
audience is.
2. Next, look at your technical writing text and determine what the author summarizes as
the criteria for a good report. Then read the article carefully, and while you are reading it,
establish your analysis of its "writing qualities." Look for good and bad points and
provide specific examples. Our class textbook supplies examples of good writing
techniques. Is the article well organized? Is there proper grammar and punctuation? Are
there tables, charts, and graphs? (Are they helpful? Are other visual aids needed?)
2
3. Analyze the introduction, the main discussion, and the terminal section for the validity
of the content. Use critical thinking and check for pseudoscience versus real science
(examples in lecture and text). Provide examples in your memo. More than likely,
articles from professional technical journals apply scientific methodologies. Note how the
authors do this.
4. Write a formal memo to Professor Wemusa with your evaluation. Do not restate or
summarize the contents of the article; focus on the specific analysis. Are the purpose and
audience properly addressed? Your memo has two major sections (readability/writing
qualities and scientific methodologies), plus you need an introduction and conclusion.
For clarity, use margin headings.
When you have evaluated the report and searched for the strong and weak points, you
should be better prepared to write and evaluate your own reports in the future. Would this
be a good professional journal for you to submit an article that you have written?
5. Give the journal article reference at the bottom of your memo in APA format.*
Find a technical article from a high quality professional technical journal**, preferably
from a key professional organization in your major, choose one within the group. Note
the differences between professional journals and magazines. This makes a difference in
trusting the validity of the data (#3 below). It must be dated 2011-2019.
! What is a Journal analysis?
A rhetorical analysis of the conventions, language, audience, intent, and content
of a specific journal from the humanities, the analysis of an essay of your choice
from the journal, a discussion of what you believe it takes to be published in
that journal.
A "journal," or "scholarly journal," is a scholarly periodical aimed at
specialists and researchers. Articles are generally written by experts in
the subject, using more technical language. They contain original research,
conclusions based on data, footnotes or endnotes, and often an abstract or
bibliography.
Pseudoscience includes beliefs, theories, or practices that have been or
are considered scientific, but have no basis in scientific fact. This could mean
they were disproved scientifically, can't be tested scientifically, or lack evidence
to support them
1. Determine its main topic and get a general idea of what it is about and how it is
organized. Make a note of what the article’s purpose is and who the article’s intended
audience is.
2. Next, look at your technical writing text and determine what the author summarizes as
the criteria for a good report. Then read the article carefully, and while you are reading it,
establish your analysis of its "writing qualities." Look for good and bad points and
provide specific examples. Our class textbook supplies examples of good writing
techniques. Is the article well organized? Is there proper grammar and punctuation? Are
there tables, charts, and graphs? (Are they helpful? Are other visual aids needed?)
2
3. Analyze the introduction, the main discussion, and the terminal section for the validity
of the content. Use critical thinking and check for pseudoscience versus real science
(examples in lecture and text). Provide examples in your memo. More than likely,
articles from professional technical journals apply scientific methodologies. Note how the
authors do this.
4. Write a formal memo to Professor Wemusa with your evaluation. Do not restate or
summarize the contents of the article; focus on the specific analysis. Are the purpose and
audience properly addressed? Your memo has two major sections (readability/writing
qualities and scientific methodologies), plus you need an introduction and conclusion.
For clarity, use margin headings.
When you have evaluated the report and searched for the strong and weak points, you
should be better prepared to write and evaluate your own reports in the future. Would this
be a good professional journal for you to submit an article that you have written?
5. Give the journal article reference at the bottom of your memo in APA format.*