HOA Selective Enforcement Review

I’m challenging an HOA violation because I believe the board is applying the rules selectively. Here’s the situation:

• I installed a short paver pathway without first obtaining ACC approval.
• During the appeal they demanded a certified drainage plan or a civil-engineer sign-off; I obtained the engineer’s signature.
• Now they have shifted the goalposts, insisting on a signature from an adjacent homeowner. The neighboring property is a rental, and the tenant has no authority to sign, so I’m effectively blocked.
• Meanwhile I have photos and written proof of similar unapproved pathways throughout the community that have never triggered violations.

I need a legal professional to:

1. Review the HOA CC&Rs, ACC guidelines, and all correspondence in light of my documentation.
2. Assess whether the board’s conduct amounts to selective enforcement or a breach of their own procedures.
3. Draft a clear, well-cited opinion letter (or short memo) I can present to the board—or, if required, escalate to a state agency or small-claims venue.

Acceptance criteria
• A written opinion (PDF or DOCX) that cites relevant clauses in my governing documents and any controlling state statutes.
• Practical next-step guidance (e.g., wording for a demand letter or appeal packet).
• Plain-language summary I can share with non-lawyer neighbors.

I’ll supply the CC&Rs, meeting minutes, engineer sign-off, photos, and timeline as soon as we start. Looking forward to your insight on leveling the playing field with this HOA.